Why do I cringe whenever someone calls me a foodie? At Maggie's party, Terry said "You are a serious foodie." She sounded as if she were paying me a compliment, but I winced. I hope not visibly.
I can hear what you're thinking. "For God's sake, you write a food blog. What more evidence do you need?" Yes, I write this blog, I have a staggering number of cookbooks. Food newsletters clog the mailbox. I shop at Farmers' Markets and I am obsessed with using the very best ingredients I can find and afford. It's like a checklist for the symptoms indicating that someone has the dreaded Foodie Bug. Still, I stubbornly insist that I am not a foodie.
For me, foodie has the unpleasant connotations of yuppie. These are people who collect restaurants and chefs the way other people collect charms on a bracelet. Their conversations are replete with allusions to their last meals at Per Se, Babbo's or Nobu's. Spending $500 on dinner isn't a rare or once-in-a-lifetime experience to be savoured at the moment and in memory; it is a way of life. The lives of yuppies and foodies are marked by a kind of collectors' mania. Another version of 'The one who dies with the most toys wins."
In Waiter Rant, the Waiter recounts this exchange with customers he characterizes as foodies.
"As the night progresses I get seated the most difficult kind of customers a water has to deal with--foodies. Foodies are usually middle-aged people who fancy themselves experts on food, wine and the finer points of table service. There's nothing wrong with being a gourmand, but foodies are not gourmands. They're gourmand wannabes. Like anything else, culinary knowledge takes time to learn. Foodies think they can watch one TV show and become the food critic for the New York Times. They're the culinary version of the guy who's had one karate lesson. They clutch their Zagat guides like it's Mao's Red Book and quote Frank Bruni like brainwashed members of the Weather Underground. Gourmet magazine's their spank mag and the Food Network's their Spice Channel. Right off the bat, I know these four guys are going to be trouble.
"Excuse me, waiter," one of the men says. "Where's the bread from?"
I tell him it's from a commercial bakery.
"Oh," the man says, putting the bread back in the basket. " I thought it was artisanal bread."
"Sorry, sir."
"Do you have any other bread?" his companion asks.
"We don't, sir."
"Well, bring me some balsamic vinegar to dip this bread in."
"It's in the bottle next to you,sir," I say.
The bread lover picks up one of the bottles of balsamic vinegar we have on the tables and holds it up to the light.
"What kind of balsamic is in here?"
I tell him. It's a good commercial brand you find in the supermarket.
"You don't have super-fancy balsamic vinegar, do you?" the man asks.
"I beg your pardon?"
"It's balsamic vinegar that costs two hundred dollars a bottle," the man says " I have it at home. You can put it on ice cream."
"I've never heard of it," I say. "But then again, I learn something new every day."
"You should know about it," the man sniffs. "You're a waiter in a Tuscan restaurant."
(Waiter Rant. Harper Collins, 2008, pp. 139-140)
I don't want to misrepresent myself as some kind of food Puritan. On the few occasions when I have had a meal in a world-class restaurant I have loved every second of it-- the great food, the subtle dance of seduction that takes place between the waiters and those of us at the table, the feeling of being cossetted and cared for, the momentary forgetting of the world outside. But I've never made of the mistake of thinking that a succession of these moments should make up my life. I've never thought that these times were my inalienable right.
For me food is all about connecting with the rest of humanity. Every meal has a sacramental dimension. Breaking bread with another person creates a bond that is not to be treated lightly. In the Middle East, if you share food with another that person can no longer be considered your enemy. "Doing lunch" has never been my idea of how to do business. It is, however, my idea of how to create friendships. Cooking for my family and my friends is a selfish pleasure. Yet, at the same time, it is the most unambiguous way I have of expressing love and affection. The hospitality of the table is central to my spiritual life.
I care deeply about where our food comes from and how it is grown and raised. I care about the people who grow our food and how farm workers are treated. I care about how food is distributed and how to create access to good food for everyone. I try to spend my dollars in accordance with my conscience.
Am I a foodie? Even if I say 'no," you may tell me that I meet enough of the criteria to be named as one of the guilty. You may be right, but I will still flinch at the label.